On October 26, Francesca Albanese, the UN Special Rapporteur on the Occupied Palestinian Territories, presented her report, "Truth Under the Rubble: Media in the Time of Genocide," to the UN General Assembly. Barred from traveling to New York by U.S. sanctions, she delivered her address remotely from Geneva.
Even before the substance of her findings could be debated in earnest, the Israeli and U.S. representatives dismissed her outright, calling her a liar, a fraud and a lunatic. When she later held a press conference to discuss the report, she noted that it was the smallest press turnout of any report she has presented.
The press corps’ reluctance to even show up only underscored the point: Western media still refuses to confront its own record. Albanese’s word for what Israel did to journalism in Gaza, and for what Western newsrooms did to help enable and obscure it, is mediacide.
I know that word well.
In spring 2024, in my last interview while I was still at the Committee to Protect Journalists, a reporter from Anadolu asked me about it. By then, the challenge of speaking plainly inside the institution had already become clear. I had already refused a promotion designed to buy my silence, and the Performance Improvement Plan that followed.
That same spring, I stood before a room of international correspondents in Washington and stated a reality that many in the press corps were still unwilling to name out loud about Palestinian journalists: "Unlike Ukraine, they had no safe haven or an exit, and they are being killed by arms provided by Western governments."
I was forced out of CPJ that April. One month later, I told stunned reporters in Washington that institutional racism is at the core of how mainstream U.S. media operates when it comes to Gaza. It is not merely a series of isolated editorial missteps or harmless errors in framing, but a structural double standard that determines whose lives matter and whose reporting is treated as credible.
In London that November, I pushed that argument further: "We need a reckoning in international media. We need to confront racism in international media." I argued then—and still believe today—that the only way we can win the fight against censorship in Gaza and Tel Aviv is by winning the fight of censorship in Western capitals. What happens on the ground cannot be separated from how it is filtered or softened in New York, Washington, and London.
On Al Jazeera that December, I pointed directly to the mechanics of that failure: Western media repeatedly amplified Israeli claims that Palestinian journalists were terrorists with no evidence. Months later, in August 2025, just days after Anas al-Sharif was assassinated by Israel in Gaza, I said on air: "This is not media balance. This is not double standard. This has been complicity from the beginning."
Last December, live on air in Doha, I insisted on speaking in English so I could ask Albanese directly for a report dedicated specifically to journalists in Palestine. I wanted the record built in the very language of institutions that had spent years avoiding it. When the call for evidence opened, I gave my testimony in February—including on CPJ. Mine was one of 89 written submissions that went into building the report.
Now, it is on the record.
Israel brands journalists as terrorists without evidence. Confirmed. The burden of proof belongs on the killer, not on our dead colleagues. Confirmed—CPJ forgot a foundational principle of press freedom. Western newsrooms laundered Israeli propaganda. Confirmed. Twelve media outlets were asked to respond to the findings before publication. Only three did.
So how did they respond once the whole world could read it?
The New York Times answered through a spokesperson, not to the public directly, but in a statement to the Times of Israel: the report "is not impartial, nor are the sources she relies on." The BBC did not answer at all when the same paper asked for comment. And I have seen nothing from CNN.
Meanwhile, in Scotland, The National put MEDIACIDE on its front page. London did not. The report was read in Arabic, Turkish, Italian, French and Spanish, and in Australia. The newsrooms it examined most closely looked away.
HonestReporting did answer. I said in 2023 that honest reporting has as much to do with honesty as Truth Social has to do with truth-telling. Its attack came on November 2, and its star witness was CPJ. It took the names CPJ removed from its own list and used them to argue that our dead colleagues were fighters. That is what happens when a watchdog agrees to play the Israeli army's game.
And CPJ itself? The report cites CPJ's research more than twenty times, including "Deadly Pattern," the report my team published five months before October 7. I have not seen one word from CPJ about it.
I waited nearly two years to speak publicly so no one could claim this was personal. It never was. This is about accountability. About media executives who demand courage from journalists while punishing it internally. About boards that confuse reputational risk with moral responsibility. About whether racism—dressed up as caution, neutrality, or fear—will continue to decide whose lives count among journalists.
This, and more, is what I will be writing about here at the Media Integrity Center. A reckoning in Western corporate media is overdue because media integrity matters. It should start with CPJ.
